The School of Athens

The School of Athens
The School of Athens by Raphael (click on picture to view short documentary from Columbia University)

Thursday 14 April 2011

Oh! What a tangled web we weave: Part 2.

Colleagues and scholars from coast to coast, across Bass Strait and all the ships at sea.

Dateline: Australia, Federal Politics.

I received some rather interesting feedback to my piece this week "Oh! What a tangled web we weave" which dealt with the lack of a requirement for truth in "political" advertising campaigns.

First, I learnt that as of January 2011 the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 had replaced the Trade Practices Act 1974.

Having been a marketer, both commercially and academically, for 26 years I was very familiar with section 52 of The Trade Practices Act: 

Trade Practices Act 1974 - Section 52 - Misleading or deceptive conduct 

(1)  A corporation shall not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.

Unfortunately, as I mentioned in my piece, this section of the Act could not stop those engaged in political advertising to mislead or deceive because they were not involved in "trade or commerce".

When I was informed that the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 had replaced the Trade Practices Act 1974, and that section 52 had been replaced by section 18 of schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010, I was anticipating, with great excitement, a marked improvement as it related to political advertising.

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 Part 2-1 Misleading or deceptive conduct

Section 18 - Misleading or deceptive conduct

(1) A person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive.

So the net sum of the change was, rather than "a corporation shall not" it now reads "a person must not".

Well that was tremendous news!  I cannot describe how delighted I was to see that change.  Note the key words "trade or commerce" had not altered.

No doubt specifying a "person" rather than a "corporation" is very helpful to enforce the principle of stopping misleading and deceptive conduct, and "must" is a stronger word than "shall", but in terms of dealing with political advertising it made no difference.  

Second, I was informed that there had been attempts made in the past to address this issue and that there were a multitude of reasons there were no restrictions in place for political advertising as there were for commercial advertising.

In short, the reasons can be summarised in one simple phrase: are you ready for this?....."It's all too hard!"  

Bandicoot bollocks!  Kangaroo cobblers!

If prohibiting misleading and deceptive conduct can be made to work in the commercial world - as it does, as it must - then it can be made to work in the political world - as it should, as it must.

And not simply for election periods, it must apply for the whole year, every year, for all political players, including: political parties, lobby groups, industry associations and corporations involving themselves in political campaigns.

This is far too important for the health of our democracy to cop out with "it's all too hard". 

Our democracy belongs to its citizens who deserve to be told the truth, not the political parties or lobby groups or the myriad of self serving rent seekers, all of whom are quite prepared to distort the truth for their own benefit.

While we cannot stop those involved in political discourse from sprouting misleading and deceptive statements in their public utterances, we can stop them from doing so in advertising.

This problem needs to be dealt with and dealt with soon, before it's too late.

For your reference, "Oh! What a tangled web we weave" is posted below.

Finally, if you think political campaigns are inclined to "dance" around the truth, have a look at these fellows, they have no equal but at least their dancing is genuine: The Nicholas Brothers   Muhammad Ali 

3 comments:

  1. Aristotle,

    Speaking of tangled webs, the ABC is the subject of attention for a pitch to GetUp.

    Colleagues and Scholars, please vote and comment on the petition to bring the ABC back to Charter.

    http://suggest.getup.org.au/forums/60819-campaign-ideas/suggestions/1684971-petition-for-abc-to-return-to-its-charter

    Spread the word of this vital initiative via Twitter and Facebook....

    Cuppa

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hillbilly Skeleton15 April 2011 at 08:17

    I'm no lawyer, but if I can get my head around the changes to the Trade Practices Act from 'a corporation shall not' to 'a person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive', then would it not now be the case that, say, John Singleton could be charged with 'misleading or deceptive conduct' as the person who owns the advertising agency that made the ads that are misleading or deceptive? Knowingly having made those deceptive and misleading ads.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hillbilly, these types of campaigns are all considered to be "political" not "trade or commerce".

    ReplyDelete

Blog Archive

Our home

Our home
Earthrise over the moon (click on picture to view film)

The pale blue dot

The pale blue dot
Earth viewed from Saturn (click on picture to view film clip)

Our neighbourhood

Our neighbourhood
The Solar System (click on picture to view film)

Our Home Galaxy

Our Home Galaxy
The Milky Way (click on picture to view film)

A sister galaxy

A sister galaxy
Andromeda (click on picture to view film)

Another sister galaxy

Another sister galaxy
Triangulum (click on picture to view short film clip)

The Local Group of Galaxies

The Local Group of Galaxies
Our Galactic Neighbourhood (click on picture to view film clip).

Our farthest view of the Universe

Our farthest view of the Universe
Hubble's farthest view (click on picture to view film clip)

The virgo super cluster of galaxies

The virgo super cluster of galaxies
Galaxies within 100 million light years (click on picture to view film clip)

Galaxies within 1 billion light years

Galaxies within 1 billion light years

Universe

Universe